"He's a pussy little bitch!"
"Sir, I have to ask you to leave. Have a nice day."
Could the clash between cultures, between responsibility, and hyper-individualism be any clearer. But what really stands out for me is the stark clash between visions and versions of masculinity.
One the one hand Customer Kevin clearly represents toxic or man-box masculinity. He seems to take great pleasure in bucking the system, showing the world through his Instagram feed that he will not obey authority. That refusal to knuckle under and an insistence on independence is baked into Western Culture and traditional manhood. And that independence is not necessarily a bad thing. Shaking up staid culture is part of the Hero's Journey and seems to be a part of psychological individuation.
But Customer Kevin displays the toxic and immature version of independent manhood by
I hope Tison's version of masculinity wins all our coming battles.
"Have a nice day."
"I'm boycotting [x] for making me wear a mask!"
"Masks take away my freedom. Freedom is more important that anything."
"Masks are for lemmings!"
"Masks are for cowards, pussies, cucks, etc."
The anti-mask comments on some posts are so livid and visceral, I can almost feel the spittle and froth through my screen. Something deep is getting triggered. Those who defend, vehemently, their "right" to flout common sense, community safety, and biological truth, are exerting themselves through the old, shallow, hierarchical model of strength. The old strength is the one characterized by:
For those of us who understand that strength is really about fostering collaborative power and creating win-win solutions, putting on a mask is an expression of solidarity, concern, and even love.
For those stuck in that old paradigm of strength, being told what to do and acceding to that demand is knuckling under to power and losing a win-lose contest and therefore allowing themselves to slip into the oppressed class. So, of course they fight and froth at the notion. Any attempt to coerce, convince, or mandate their actions are going to be met with more hostility and spittle because they believe they are locked in an existential battle for power and survival, not a debate over public health best practices.
Those of us who are able to value the community and collective power/safety, tend to wear masks without too much fuss. I know I feel caring, and connected to my community when I wear a mask. I am putting it on to protect others. I am showing my steadiness and my ability to make a tiny sacrifice for those around me. I feel upright and strong.
And, yes, because I am acting in accordance with my value system, I feel a little righteous about my decision. Maybe I even act a little righteous or condescending about my choice. But there can be no true case made for both-sider-ism. Both choices are not equally valid. Wearing a mask protects others, will help prevent death, and actually speed the re-opening of businesses and institutions.
In times of collective danger, collective action is necessary. Unfortunately, those operating under the old paradigm of strength are ever fearful of being told what to do lest they become one of the oppressed. Their attempts to protect themselves from this fate endanger us all.
I don't know, really, how to help the anti-maskers stand-down from their self-protective position. They crave power and freedom when self-sacrifice and community solidarity are called for. I don't know how to reach across the paradigm divide. Maybe some of you reading this post have ideas. I'd love to hear them.
You can hear more about my own personal journey from Old Strength to New Strength in my latest TEDx talk.
Are you watching videos of the protests in and in front of the state capitals demanding and end to stay-at-home orders and business closures? Do you see the pictures of people, mostly men and two of them the leaders of our Executive Branch, pictures of men not wearing masks? Do you hear their chants and sense their entitlement and shake your head? Maybe I should title this blog post “Childish Masculinity During a Pandemic.”
But, unfortunately, these scenes, these selfish, nonsensical actions are totally embedded products of traditional or toxic masculinity. TM demands that adult men engage in hyper-individuality modeled after movie western heroes. Collectivity, working together, asking for or even offering help is a sign of weakness. There are exceptions, sure. Team sports and the military depend on collective action and camaraderie. But highlight reels and Bronze Stars celebrate individual achievements, not cooperation.
They know, though, don’t they, that they are wrong and acting against our true nature. The fact that these protesters have to get kitted up in their body armour and semi-autos tells me they know that they are play acting, outside of authentic humanity. The fact that they have to get together in the 100s to demand individual choice, shows me that they still crave community and togetherness, they just can’t admit it and join the broad consensus. Those poisoned by toxic masculinity would rather risk all our collective health for showy displays of hollow manhood.
So, brothers and sisters, I salute those of you who have the Deep Strength of patience, collective concern, and broad empathy. I stand with you men who are truly protecting your families by staying home as much as possible. Heros wear masks and wash their hands. Thank you.